What to Do When ABA Therapy Is Not Working

When ABA Therapy Is Not Working: Causes, Solutions & Next Steps

May 6, 2025
No Comments

Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) therapy is one of the most widely used and researched interventions for children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). With a reported success rate of over 89% in improving communication, social skills, and adaptive behaviors, ABA therapy has helped many families achieve meaningful progress.

However, not every child responds to ABA in the same way. For some, ABA therapy outcomes fall short of expectations, leading parents and caregivers to ask: Why is ABA not working? What are the problems with ABA therapy, and what steps can families take when progress stalls?

This comprehensive guide explores the reasons ABA therapy may not work for every child, the signs to watch for, the role of individualized care, and how to advocate for your child’s needs.

Understanding ABA Therapy and Its Goals

ABA therapy is grounded in the science of behaviorism. It aims to teach new skills and reduce behaviors that interfere with learning or daily life. ABA therapy techniques include positive reinforcement, discrete trial training (DTT), natural environment teaching (NET), and functional behavior assessments (FBA). The process is data-driven, with therapists tracking progress and adjusting interventions as needed.

ABA therapy outcomes can include improvements in:

Communication and language
Social skills
Academic readiness
Self-care and daily living skills
Reduction in challenging behaviors

Despite these benefits, ABA therapy is not a one-size-fits-all solution. Each child brings unique strengths, needs, and learning styles, which means that ABA must be carefully tailored to be effective.

Why Is ABA Not Working? Common Reasons and Challenges

1. Lack of Individualization

One of the most cited reasons for ABA therapy not working is a lack of personalization. ABA therapy thrives on individualized plans, but when therapy becomes generic or fails to consider the “why” behind a child’s behaviors, progress may stall. A one-size-fits-all approach can overlook sensory sensitivities, communication preferences, and learning styles, making it difficult for the child to engage or benefit from therapy.

2. Negative or Fear-Based Environment

ABA therapy should be positive and supportive. If sessions rely on negative reinforcement, punishment, or strict demands for compliance, children may feel anxious, stressed, or even fearful. Forcing eye contact, discouraging natural behaviors like fidgeting, or ignoring a child’s comfort level can create resistance and disengagement, leading to poor outcomes.

3. Highly Structured and Repetitive Sessions

While structure is important, overly rigid or repetitive sessions can overwhelm children, especially those with sensory sensitivities. Too much repetition without variation or real-life application can cause frustration or boredom, reducing motivation and learning.

4. Unpleasant or Traumatic Experiences

If therapy is experienced as unpleasant, stressful, or traumatic, children may withdraw or resist further participation. This can be due to mismatched techniques, unrealistic expectations, or a lack of respect for the child’s autonomy and preferences. Trauma or distress during therapy can have long-term impacts on mental health and self-esteem.

5. Inadequate Communication and Collaboration

Effective ABA therapy requires ongoing communication between therapists, parents, and other caregivers. If families are not involved in goal-setting, or if therapists do not adjust strategies based on feedback, therapy may lose relevance and effectiveness.

6. Insufficient Intensity or Duration

Some children may not receive enough hours of therapy per week, or therapy may not be sustained over a long enough period to see significant results. ABA therapy outcomes are often linked to the intensity and duration of intervention, though too much intensity without regard for the child’s needs can also be counterproductive.

7. Misaligned Goals

Sometimes, therapy goals may not align with the child’s developmental stage, interests, or family priorities. When goals feel irrelevant or unattainable, motivation and progress can suffer.

Problem With ABA Therapy: Perspectives from the Autistic Community

The question “Why is ABA not working?” is not only clinical but deeply personal, especially from an autistic perspective. Many autistic adults who received ABA as children have voiced concerns about the therapy’s focus on compliance, suppression of autistic traits, and lack of attention to emotional needs. Common criticisms include:

Suppression of Identity: Some feel that ABA’s focus on reducing autistic behaviors can send the message that their natural ways of communicating or self-regulating are “wrong.”
Lack of Consent: Intensive ABA often starts at a young age, raising concerns about the child’s ability to consent or express discomfort.
Emphasis on Compliance: A strong focus on compliance can make individuals more vulnerable to exploitation or abuse later in life.
Overlooking Sensory Needs: Sensory sensitivities are sometimes ignored, leading to distress or disengagement.
Emotional Impact: Some report increased anxiety, depression, or PTSD symptoms as a result of negative or traumatic therapy experiences.

These perspectives highlight the importance of ethical, individualized, and child-centered ABA practices that respect neurodiversity and prioritize well-being.

Statistics on ABA Therapy: Success Rates and Limitations

Statistical data shows that ABA therapy has a high overall success rate, with studies reporting over 89% effectiveness in improving communication, social skills, and adaptive behaviors in children with ASD. However, these statistics on ABA therapy also reveal that outcomes vary widely based on:

The child’s age at the start of therapy
The severity of autism symptoms
The quality and individualization of the therapy
Family involvement and support
The therapist’s training and approach

Not every child will experience the same level of improvement, and some may not respond to ABA at all. Recognizing these limitations is key to setting realistic expectations and making informed decisions.

How Do I Know If ABA Therapy Is Working?

Parents and caregivers often wonder how to measure ABA therapy outcomes and determine if therapy is effective. Signs that ABA therapy is working include:

Steady progress toward individualized goals
Increased communication, social engagement, or independence
Reduction in challenging behaviors
Skills generalizing to new settings (home, school, community)
Positive engagement and enthusiasm during sessions

If progress stalls for several months or if the child appears distressed, withdrawn, or resistant, it may be time to re-evaluate the therapy plan.

When to Stop ABA Therapy

There is no universal answer for when to stop ABA therapy. Decisions should be based on:

Achievement of therapy goals
The child’s age, developmental stage, and changing needs
Family priorities and quality of life
The child’s willingness and engagement

If ABA therapy is not working despite adjustments or if it causes distress, families should consider alternative approaches or a break from therapy.

Alternatives and Adjustments When ABA Therapy Is Not Working

If ABA therapy is not working, families have options:

Reassess and Individualize: Work with your therapy team to re-evaluate goals, strategies, and session structure.
Change Therapists or Providers: Sometimes, a better fit can make a significant difference.
Incorporate Other Therapies: Speech therapy, occupational therapy, and developmental approaches (such as DIR/Floortime or TEACCH) can complement or replace ABA.
Listen to the Child: Respect the child’s feedback, preferences, and comfort level.
Focus on Quality of Life: Shift goals to prioritize independence, self-advocacy, and well-being.

ABA Therapy from an Autistic Perspective: Listening and Learning

Autistic voices are increasingly shaping the conversation around ABA therapy. Many advocate for approaches that:

Respect neurodiversity and individual differences
Prioritize consent and autonomy
Address sensory and emotional needs
Focus on meaningful, functional skills rather than compliance or normalization

Families and providers can learn from these perspectives to create more supportive, effective, and compassionate interventions.

How Kids n Heart ABA Can Help

At Kids n Heart ABA, we understand that every child’s journey is unique. Our approach addresses many of the common problems with ABA therapy by:

Personalizing Every Plan: We assess each child’s strengths, needs, and preferences, creating individualized goals and strategies.
Family-Centered Care: We involve parents and caregivers in every step, ensuring therapy is relevant and collaborative.
Positive, Respectful Methods: Our therapists use positive reinforcement, never punishment or fear-based techniques.
Continuous Assessment: We track progress closely and adjust plans as needed to maximize outcomes and engagement.
Listening to Autistic Perspectives: We value autistic voices and adapt our practices to respect neurodiversity, autonomy, and well-being.
Flexible Services: Whether your child needs in-home, clinic-based, or community sessions, we tailor our approach for the best fit.

Kids n Heart ABA is committed to helping children reach their full potential, even if that means adjusting or rethinking traditional ABA strategies.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What are the disadvantages of ABA therapy?

Disadvantages can include lack of individualization, potential for overly rigid or repetitive sessions, emotional distress if therapy is not adapted to the child’s needs, and historical concerns about compliance-focused or punishment-based approaches. Some autistic individuals report negative experiences, especially if therapy suppresses their natural behaviors or ignores sensory needs.

What is the success rate of ABA therapy?

Studies report that ABA therapy has an over 89% success rate in improving communication, social skills, and adaptive behaviors in children with ASD. However, outcomes vary based on individual factors, therapy quality, and family involvement.

How do I know if ABA therapy is working?

Signs include steady progress toward goals, increased communication and independence, reduced challenging behaviors, and positive engagement in sessions. If progress stalls or the child is distressed, it may be time to re-evaluate the approach.

When to stop ABA therapy?

ABA therapy may be stopped when goals are met, the child’s needs change, or if therapy is not effective or causes distress. Decisions should be made collaboratively with the family and therapy team.

Conclusion: Ready for a Fresh Approach?

If you feel like ABA therapy is not working for your child, you’re not alone-and you’re not out of options. The key is to listen, adapt, and seek support that truly fits your child’s needs and your family’s values.

Curious how a personalized, compassionate approach can make a difference? Call Kids n Heart ABA today for a no-pressure consultation. Let’s work together to find the path that helps your child thrive-whether it’s a new direction in ABA or something entirely different. Your child’s journey is unique, and we’re here to support every step.

ABA therapy not working? There’s always another way forward. Let’s find it together with Kids n Heart ABA.

Sources:

When ABA Therapy Is Not Working: Causes, Solutions & Next Steps